The Diverse faces of the Second Demographic transition in Europe
Discutant : Henri Leridon (Ined) Président de séance : Laurent Toulemon (Ined)
This paper discusses the concept of the second demographic
transition (SDT) and its relevance for explaining the ongoing
changes in family and fertility patterns across Europe. It takes a
closer look at the shifts in values and attitudes related to
family, reproduction, and children, and their representation in
different chapters in this collection. It re-examines the link
between the second demographic transition and fertility, highlights
its strong positive association with fertility at later
childbearing ages, and suggests that the transition does not
necessarily lead to sub-replacement fertility levels. Subsequently,
it provides an extensive discussion on the progression of the SDT
behind the former ‘Iron Curtain.’ To explain some apparent
contradictions in this process, it employs a conceptual model of
‘readiness, willingness, and ability’ (RWA) advocated by Lesthaeghe
and Vanderhoeft (2001). It also explores the multifaceted nature of
the second demographic transition between different social groups,
and points out an apparent paradox: whereas lower-educated
individuals often embrace values that can be characterised as
rather traditional, they also frequently manifest family behaviour
associated with the transition, such as non-marital childbearing,
high partnership instability, and high prevalence of long-term
cohabitation. This suggests that there may be two different
pathways of the progression of the second demographic transition.
The concluding section points out the role of structural
constraints for the diffusion of the transition among disadvantaged
social strata, highlights the importance of the ‘gender revolution’
for the SDT trends, and discusses the usefulness of the SDT
framework.